I’ve posted about the teams I’m more optimistic about than others (Michigan, Oregon, Syracuse, Iowa State, and Virginia) as well as some I’m more pessimistic about (Oklahoma, Texas, Washington, Iowa, or Wisconsin). Now I go on the record with some picks. I’ve added additional commentary about how these teams would fare against Clemson should they meet in the College Football Playoff. Enjoy and feel free to tell me why all my picks (except Clemson winning the ACC) are woefully wrong.
Clemson over Virginia
The offense could be the best in school history with most of the offensive line and key play makers returning. Concerns at TE and Slot-WR are legitimate, but not dire.
The defense will likely regress slightly with the top 5 defensive lineman leaving, but the secondary should improve as both safeties return and CB Trayvon Mullen is replaced with bolstered depth. With Florida State and Louisville down, Clemson is the best team in the ACC by a wide margin.
This pick is largely a statement that Bryce Perkins is the best QB in the Coastal Division. Perkins ran for 923 yards and 9 TDs while throwing for 2,680 and 25 TDs with a 64% completion percentage last season. Even with that, their offense wasn’t great and now they must replace their best WR in Olamide Zaccheaus and RB Jordan Ellis. The defense, which was already good, returns seven starters.
UVA has never won the Coastal division, but they may not have an opportunity this good for a while. Miami has several unknowns with a new head coach and a redshirt freshman starting at QB. Virginia Tech should have big improvements on defense, but was only 6-7 last season and travels to Charlottesville this year. While UVA may have the horses to win the Coastal Division, Perkins can’t be expected to keep up with Trevor Lawrence without weapons like Justyn Ross, Tee Higgins, and Travis Etienne on his side.
Michigan over Nebraska
Michigan hasn’t won the Big 10 since 2004, but they’re getting plenty of hype coming into 2019. Jim Harbaugh took over a 5-win team and quickly turned them into a 10-win team. Now that he’s brought Michigan back to relevance, the fans are clamoring for that next step.
Josh Gattis comes over from Alabama to run the offense. He plans to open things up with a no-huddle spread offense, something quite different for Michigan. It’s not so different for QB Shea Patterson though, who played under a similar system at Ole Miss prior to his transfer. Michigan loses their top two RBs and will likely rely heavily on Patterson’s arm.
Michigan returns five starters on defense, but two of the departures are Rashan Gary and Devin Bush Jr. The pair of defensive stars sat out the Peach Bowl and the Wolverines subsequently surrendered 41 points to Florida. DE Chase Winovich is also gone after being a third round pick by the Patriots. Strong recruiting and great coaching by DC Don Brown makes this less scary though.
If Clemson is to face Michigan in the playoff, it’ll likely mean the Wolverines found success with a new spread offense and the defense avoided a major drop off after losing several stars. In that case, they’ll be dangerous. Still, Clemson has so many more weapons on offense that should provide the firepower to carry the day.
Amidst all the talk about last year’s three big playoff QBs – Trevor Lawrence, Tua Tagovailoa, and Kyler Murray – Dwayne Haskin’s excellence gets lost in the shuffle. Haskins threw for 4,831 yards and 50 TDs! He had a 70% completion percentage and just 8 INTs. He gets replaced by a first time starter in Justin Fields. Fields transferred from UGA after getting stuck behind QB Jake Fromm and inexplicably got a waiver to play immediately. The Buckeyes only return four on offense and will likely experience some level of drop off from last season.
Their defense struggled last year to the tune of 245 passing yards allowed per game. They gave up 31 points to Oregon State, 49 points to Purdue (their lone loss), 31 points to Nebraska, and 51 to Maryland. They return 9 starters and replaced DC Greg Schiano with Greg Mattison. They should be stronger on that side of the ball.
Ohio State doesn’t challenge themselves in the non-conference, but they play at Nebraska, at Northwestern, and vs. Wisconsin from the Big 10 West. They also go to Ann Arbor. I’m not sure they can avoid a notable drop off on offense (they finished second in passing yardage per game last season) and I think folks are overlooking how good of a Coach Urban Meyer was, because of the controversy that engulfed last season.
If they make the playoff however, it likely means I was wrong about their offensive regression, Justin Fields met or exceeded expectations, and Meyer wasn’t missed. If their offense is as strong as last season, but now paired with a good defense they will be hard to beat. Ohio State is not one of my playoff picks, but their upside is high so if they’re good enough to make it, they could put up much more of a fight than the last time they played Clemson and lost 31-0.
The Big 10 West is wide open. Any pick here (except Illinois) is totally defensible, but Wisconsin plays Michigan State, Michigan, and Ohio State. Iowa has a lot of pieces to replace (their two star TEs went in the top 20 picks last season). Meanwhile, Nebraska gets Wisconsin, Northwestern, and Iowa at home - likely the three most important divisional games for them). Nebraska lost a lot of close games and could continue their progress under Scott Frost. Adrian Martinez is likely the best QB in the division (barring a Hunter Johnson breakout), which tilts the division ever so slightly in their favor.
Oklahoma over Iowa State
The Sooners had arguably the best offense in NCAA history in 2018. They averaged an NCAA-record 8.6 yards per play. Kyler Murray threw for a ridiculous 4,361 yards and 42-7 TD INT ratio. Now they have to avoid a major drop-off while losing four starting offensive linemen, leading receiver Marquise Brown, and Heisman-winning QB Kyler Murray. They almost certainly will take a step back offensively, but how big it is will depend on how transfer QB Jalen Hurts performs.
In Jalen Hurts’ best year as a starter at Alabama (2016), he threw for 2,780 yards with a 17-1 TD-INT ratio. Moving to the Big 12 should help him boost his numbers as he trades the LSUs and Auburns of the world for offensive-oriented teams like Texas Tech and Oklahoma State. Still, he will need to show skills growth if the Sooner offense is going to avoid a major regression.
On defense, they were simply awful. They were dead last nationally in passing defense and failed the eye test miserably. Alabama carved them up in the playoff with simple slant routes. They often looked hapless. They allowed 40 points to Kansas! They return nine defensive starters and bring in Alex Grinch from Ohio State to be the new defensive coordinator. There’s reason to think the defense can get a lot better – they can only go up.
Big questions remain around their offensive line and replacing Kyler Murray, but if they make the playoff, it likely means the offensive line was fine, Jalen Hurts totally changed his game and threw for over 3,500 yards, and the defensive improved immensely. They may be less likely than Michigan or Ohio State to achieve that upside, but their upside may be the highest.
The Longhorns are the en vogue pick this year, but some of that may be due to recency bias after they upset the Georgia Bulldogs in the Sugar Bowl. They return only two starters on defense. Seven of their nine wins last year were by a touchdown or less. Predictably, the advanced stats were not high on Texas and ranked them just 32nd even after beating UGA.
With QB Sam Ehlinger and WR Collin Johnson coming back, their offense should be strong, but nothing special in the offensively-excellent Big 12. Their defense may take a step back. With road trips to TCU and Iowa State - not to mention a non-conference home game against LSU - there are plenty of spots besides the Red River Showdown for a slip up. If the Longhorns prove me wrong and make the playoff, I’d take this matchup if I’m Clemson. The Longhorns would have a very difficult time slowing the Tiger offense.
The offense loses WR Hakeem Butler and RB David Montgomery, but they return QB Brock Purdy who was the Big 12 True Freshman of the Year by ESPN. The Cyclones have become one of the only teams in the Big 12 with a consistently solid defense - along with TCU. Last season, they ranked 28th nationally in defense by the S&P+, second only to TCU among Big 12 teams. Both sides of the ball return seven starters and while they go to Norman, OK, they get Texas, TCU, and Oklahoma State - the three biggest swing games - at home. They won’t threaten for the playoff, but they could make an appearance in the conference championship game if they can upset Texas in Ames.
Oregon over Utah
The surprising return of QB Justin Herbert means Oregon returns essentially their entire offense from last season. QB Justin Herbert was projected as a first rounder, but elected to return anyway. While NFL executives love him, he needs to be more consistent. His stats (3,151 passing yards 28-9 TD-INT ratio) aren’t that eye popping and he struggled in a few games, most notably in the Ducks’ inexplicable 15-44 at Arizona. The added experience may help him take it to the next level, as will an offensive line that brings back all five starters.
The defense returns seven starters, but replaces defensive coordinator Jim Leavitt. There shouldn’t be a drop off, but coaching changes always bring uncertainty.
Oregon opens the season in Arlington, TX against Auburn and plays Washington on the road. That makes their path to the playoff far less certain, but Washington has defensive questions and Auburn will still be figuring out their QB situation in week one. If Oregon can escape Arlington, they have a very good chance to go 12-0 or 11-1 and enter the Pac-12 Championship game with a shot at a playoff berth.
Mario Cristobal wasn’t the most lauded hire when Oregon scrambled and chose him following Willie Taggart’s departure for FSU, but he has the program pointed in the right direction. I’m not sure any team in the Pac-12 has the upside to beat Clemson, Alabama, or Georgia in the playoff, but Oregon is probably the most dangerous in the conference.
Last season, the Utes were 6-3 when they lost QB Tyler Huntley and star RB Zack Moss. They won their last three regular season games, but fizzled out without them in their two postseason games - losses to Washington and Northwestern. Now, both are back as part of an offense that returns seven starters overall. Utah has somewhat taken the mantle of the most physical and tough team in the Pac-12 from Stanford, and their defense, which ranked #2 in the conference in points per game allowed and #1 in rushing yards allowed, returns seven starters. They go to USC and to Washington, but otherwise have a very manageable schedule. They don’t have the raw talent to compete with elite programs, but they should win the south and could win the conference. Given their favorable path, a playoff berth isn’t completely unrealistic. That would be an ideal matchup for Clemson.
Alabama over Georgia
The biggest threat to Clemson is undoubtedly Alabama. There have been five college football playoffs thus far. Alabama has come out on top in two of them. Both of their titles succeeded losses in the playoff the year prior (2014: Ohio State; 2016: Clemson). It was clear in 2017 that Alabama was seeking revenge. Tony Brown’s crazy post-game rant showed he had been stewing all year following the loss to Clemson in Tampa. That’s what Clemson will have to overcome in 2019 to repeat.
Alabama will have a very experienced offense. They’ll likely start one redshirt freshman on the offensive line, but all their other starters could be juniors and seniors. Tua gets all three of his starting wide receivers back making for the only QB/WR grouping that can rival Clemson’s.
At running back, Alabama has to replace both Josh Jacobs (drafted 24th to Raiders) and Damien Harris (drafted 3rd Round – 87th Patriots), but Najee Harris returns. Behind him, Brian Robinson Jr. who is a junior seems ready for a larger role, only collecting 87 career carries thus far. He’s a former four-star recruit that holds the single-game 6A Alabama high-school rushing record (437 yards).
They return seven defensive starters. Most notably, their secondary should improve. At cornerback, Patrick Surtain II and Josh Jobe return for their sophomore campaigns and Trevon Diggs returns for his senior campaign. At safety, junior Xavier McKinney and seniors Shyheim Carter and Jared Mayden are back. The three-man defensive line must replace two starters, most notably Quinnen Williams. Much like Clemson, the strength of their defense could shift towards the back-end.
Steve Sarkisian and Pete Golding will coordinate the offense and defense respectively. Both have worked with Saban before (Golding was an internal promotion). The hope is that they know what they have signed up for and won’t quickly vacate their roles. If a renewed focus is brought to the coaching staff that’ll help too.
Alabama’s secondary will put up more of a fight if they face Clemson’s receivers again, but they’ll still be disadvantaged. An even further improved Alabama offense will score more than 16 against a Power Ranger-less Tiger defense though. Anyone who beats Clemson will have to do it in shootout fashion, and Alabama fueled by revenge is the team best positioned to do it.
QB Jake Fromm and RB D’Andre Swift return for their junior seasons in what could be the Dawgs best chance for a National Title for the next couple years. They return six starters on offense and seven on defense, and should once again be one of the five or six best teams in the country. They have a tricky path though as they get Notre Dame in the non-conference, Texas A&M and Auburn from the SEC West, Florida from their own division, and of course Alabama likely awaiting in a potential SEC Championship game.
The offense was third in the country per S&P+ advanced statistics rankings last season. QB Jake Fromm is incredibly efficient. He had a 67% completion percentage and 30-6 TD-INT ratio. He didn’t air it out much though. His 2,749 passing yards were 1,217 fewer than Tua Tagovailoa and 531 fewer than Trevor Lawrence. He has been called a “game manager.” To some extent it’s true; he’s just a very good one. With Jim Chaney’s departure to Tennessee, James Coley – who previously called the plays under Al Golden at Miami – will take over play calling duties. He may give Fromm more chances downfield. UGA only passed the ball 39% of the time last year. Expect that number to rise in Fromm’s junior season.
One complicating issue is the loss of all their key WRs as well as their starting TE. Running back D’Andre Swift’s 297 receiving yards is the most among returning players. That could prevent Fromm from building on last year and the Georgia offense from becoming more balanced.
The defense returns seven starters, but has the tough task of replacing CB Deandre Baker, who is now a New York Giant. They must do a better job of getting to the QB. They only had 24 sacks all of last season. Their 1.7 sacks per game ranked just 100th nationally. They brought in Jermaine Johnson from Independence (Kansas) Community College (made famous by Netflix’s Last Chance U) to help. They also have six former five-stars on defense so they have the talent, but need to develop it quickly.
A new play caller with a potentially more aggressive offense may make UGA a little less of a sure bet, but the upside it offers is potentially what UGA needs to get over the last hurdle. If Fromm and a totally new WR-corps can pull it off, Georgia has a chance to take the next step. If they try and fail, a small step back is possible.
College Football Playoff Picks
Listed in order of confidence to make the playoff:
Oregon and Ohio State are next on my list.
If you’d like to hear my pick of how a potential 14-0 Clemson would fare against a 14-0 Alabama, you can listen on the Clemson Pawcast. If you aren’t already subscribed to the @ClemsonPawcast, find it on the Apple podcasting app and subscribe there.
Which of the following has the best chance to make the College Football Playoff?
This poll is closed