Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: NFL Owners Vote to Change Trade Deadline

Charmin Ultra Tigers Bring Back Bowden Memories

Thats your game synopsis from me this week.

What is there to say after a performance like that? We put up the best run since 2000 and end it with the worst loss in Swinney's tenure. As I was telling FF last night at halftime, this season feels just like 2000. We were killing people with Woody, TZach and Gardner, and our defense looked like hot garbage the whole time. He and I knew once we faced a good enough defense that we'd lose, and GT had a good enough one then, and George Godsey lit Reggie Herring up like a Christmas tree. The team fell to pieces after that loss.

Will this 2011 team do the same? Theres a good chance. I see the same issues we had in Week 1 creep back in slowly over these last few games, and now theyre all worse.

Our defense is certainly the worst I've seen since Herring left, but I think this has to be one of the worst defenses in my memory. There is no excuse for their performance over the season. Last night wasn't totally on them, because we had shit field position, but when the other team can just line up and bulldoze you, and your DBs are all completely lost out there, it doesnt make the defense innocent.

Our LBs have grown progressively worse over the entire season, this with one of the best LB coaches around running the show. They sit back and wait for plays instead of pressing gaps. They don't collision receivers going up the seam of the coverage, and when they blitz, they walk right up to a OL and just stand there. It feels like paralysis by analysis.

Our DEs get reached on every outside run play, so we don't set the edge on anyone, ever. They look slow and tired. Goodman got OUTRUN to the sideline by Glennon last night, when he started out in good enough position to make the play in the backfield for a loss. Branch was completely ineffective. Who will save this DL next year?

DBs never get off blocks, which we've bemoaned here for years, but when you play press coverage and don't even have your hands in position to make a jam on a receiver, how the hell are you going to deny him a release? We show inside leverage, and then the guy just runs inside the CB without being touched. That is pathetic. You put your  hands on his inside number and deny that inside move when you have inside leverage. We spend the whole time handsignaling and yelling at each other, and by the time we know who to cover, the offense has snapped the ball and the receiver is open. Gilchrist did this shit last year at the Nickel and he'd get killed inside because he was looking at Hall and checking the coverage instead of his slot receiver, now they ALL do it.

This scheme is NFL-based, but clearly either these guys cannot handle it, or our coaches cannot teach it. Since I know these coaches have coached with the best there are around, and know how to teach something, I can only put the blame on the HC's practice philosophies and the idea that they are being given too much information to make decisions off of.

We show 10 fronts, and it needs to come down to 2 or 3, because these guys don't know how to hold a gap and sometimes don't even know which gap to hold. Brad Brownell should've proved what we say all along: if you have good fundamentals you can get more and more complex, but if you don't, you have to KISS. If you get complex with no damn fundamentals, you get Clemson defense. Saban's defense is highly complex, but his teams have good fundamentals to start from, and he/Smart can simplify and teach his defense. Our coaches don't have a chance, and its because they have taught pisspoor fundamentals from the start.

If you want to learn how to tackle, I can teach you. You get in your stance, and you hit the mufugher across from you over and over. You put your head under his chin, wrap up and drive through. Get up and do it again. Once you do that, you go to full speed hitting on bags and work on your damn pursuit angles. You can tackle on a mat, or pillow bags, but you have to hit somebody. Thats the old school way to learn, Steele knows it, Dan Brooks knows it, and thats clearly not what we are doing. We have some the worst angles I can recall from a CU defense, and we can't wrap up at any position on the defense. We play pattycake in practice.

Learning to run block is 90% effort. There is technique to run-blocking, which we haven't had in a decade, but you have to WANT TO move a man against his will. Our OL does not grasp this fact. Dalton Freeman would just come out and say "We were confused by what they were doing" when we lose, and then Walker would say how much pride we take in run blocking. Bullshit. They play pattycake in practice.

I want people to go back and watch your game tapes from this year if you have them, and tell me how many teams we blew off the ball. Compare that to how many we should blow off the ball.

Tell me how many times you see a Clemson lineman not touching anyone when the whistle is blown.

Tell me how many times you see a Clemson lineman with his pads low enough to make an effective block on somebody.

Tell me how many drives Antoine McClain killed by not blocking a soul.

Tell me how many times we run a bucksweep where you don't see Antoine block anyone at all.

If Phil Price, the walk-on, is our best OL, we have a problem here. We lost him and the whole line went to crap yesterday. He doesn't have half the athletic ability of someone like Thomas, or the strength of McClain, but 10x the WANT TO of any other lineman.This Charmin Softness starts with the S&C coach that sees and works with them 365 days a year, the same one we've had since Bowden, and the end responsibility is on Dabo Swinney for not seeing and rectifying the problem. If he let the team have less contact by request, then he needs his ass kicked first. I want Morris to take over our OL this week and put boots to asses, otherwise SC's DL will eat them for lunch.

Dan Pearman is approaching Jack Hines territory. Thats all i can say about our Special Teams.

I didn't like some of Chad's playcalling yesterday, and I'm sure most had similar complaints. I understand the need to force Tajh to take checkdowns, but you still need to push the ball. We have speed, let them use it.

I understand that he wants to make Tajh a run threat, but he does it by forcing a playcall instead of running a read option play. I'd rather try the read option on a short yardage situation (2nd & 5, 2nd & 3, 3rd & 3) and see what happens. I don't think Tajh will be anything more than an effective runner here. He won't be a big threat to a defense like a Dantzler, and only needs to be able to scramble for 5-7 here and there to be effective. I don't see the need to force it. I don't see the need to force the inside zone for effect and abandon the Jet series either.

For this offense to be effective again, we need guys that will learn to hold the ball the right way and receivers who work to get open, because I didn't see that from many yesterday. We need Tajh to get his head right and focus on making his progressions, but most of all we need an OL that shows up to play football. I don't think any offense can go further than the OL can take it. If we can MOVE PEOPLE inside, then they can't drop 8 into coverage.

But I put the full blame for lack of energy and focus in this game, and the previous few games, on Dabo Swinney. That is his job to handle. He sets the tone in practice all week. This loss doesn't go pn the OL, the defense, lack of Sammy, or Tajh's play. It goes to Dabo. I don't want to hear him tell TOB that he's happy for him or that he's proud of Paul Johnson. I don't want every game to be like winning the Academy award either and give the coach a gatorade bath every damn week.

There will not be a film review of this game. First, theres a holiday, and second. I have no impetus to watch that shit again.

Its Hate Week, let the hate flow.

Comment 44 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Shakin The Southland

Post Draft Sunday Thoughts

Apr 2012 by FIGUREFOUR - 15 comments

Spring Game Open Thread

Apr 2012 by FIGUREFOUR - 72 comments

Orange Bowl Game Film Review

Jan 2012 by DrB - 7 comments

2011 Football Season Review

Jan 2012 by DrB - 17 comments

Comments

Display:

Here's why the team plays like shit, they dont practice

Swinney’s leadership council meets every week to discuss ways to keep the team focused and fresh. Swinney listens. The leadership council suggested at one point this season practicing fewer days in full pads and Swinney applied the suggestion.

Read more: http://m.thetandd.com/sports/article_2bbc4a62-0cf4-11e1-a868-001cc4c002e0.html#ixzz1eIgYiPNK

No wonder they cant block or tackle. Pussy practices leads to pussy play on the field.

by IhateUSuC on Nov 20, 2011 8:59 PM EST reply actions  

Tigers

Dr. B,
      First, let me say that I enjoy your site and your detailed analysis. However, I must respectively disagree with some of your points. You sound knowlegeable of the game and you make excellent points. I am not sure how many collegiate practices you have watched, especially at this point of the year, but I have had the opportunity to watch a number of different programs practice and Clemson is not practicing any differently than most programs at this point of the year. Furthermore, it is very evident that depth is a major issue with this team along the defensive and offensive front. There is clearly a lack of quality players behind the front line starters. Our defensive front starters play more plays than the majority teams in our league. THEY ARE TIRED! It is amazing to me that they have held up as long as they have. Clemson’s defense lost a lot of experience off last years defense. The secondary is very young at the corner position and Hall’s injury is clearly preventing him from being a real playmaker. Linebacker play is very poor and it has not improved as much as I would have thought. But, I can assure you that Kevin Steele has not forgotten how to teach tackling over night.
Our offensive line to me is the most dissapointing facet of our team. This bunch has never been good at run blocking. Run blocking is technique and attitude. McClain has the body, but does not know assignments and plays with very little effort in my opinon a lot of the time. Freemen and Walker are the two best lineman we have and they are good ballplayers. But, you cannot pin this solely on the offensive line. At least twice I saw Dwayne Allen completely bust a good looking play because he flat out gave no effort in executing his block. No effort at all. It was clear after watching the play several times that he knew who he was supposed to block and simply gave no effort. This team got beat because there was no sense of urgency. The comebacks earlier in the season have given them a sense of complacency. If Clemson can simply hold on to the football and execute the play called they will get back to playing good football, but our best players (Dwayne Allen….and others) have to play well. Clemson coaches have to hold them accountable and if they are not going to play hard in all facets of the game then someone else needs to be given a look. Just my two cents….

by oddfront34 on Nov 20, 2011 9:50 PM EST reply actions  

I agree that they are tired, we showcased the snap counts

but these fundamentals were not there in Week 1, and have not improved whatsoever.

if the backups cannot be taught proper fundamentals either, then its totally on the defensive staff.

by DrB on Nov 20, 2011 9:53 PM EST up reply actions  

Good post

I have always wondered how our practices are comparing to others.. I think Dabo is just too nice and too cool with the players. I think as a head coach you either have to be a guy who the players will run through a brick wall for, a guy that all the players fear but respect, or a Belichick type master strategist.. Dabo has not reached either of these, I think his best chance is at the first option, but until he gets there, and we get some depth, there will be let down games.

"Just because you've had 2 or 3 good games doesn't mean anything right now. It's not the first 3 games you're going to be remembered by." - The Chad

by scgreatest803 on Nov 20, 2011 10:11 PM EST up reply actions  

I wonder what the practices are like as well. But Clemson's practices are closed to the public

So, I dont know how this guy says he watches us practice.

It’s obvious that this team is lost and doesnt have fundamentals down. When those things are missing you must practice them. You’re not going to get better by talking about being tougher or tackling better. You must practice it. And this thing about “Clemson doesnt practice any different than any other team…” Well so whoopee freaking do. If everybody was jumping off a bridge would you too? This team needs to practice what they dont do well. If its hitting, then practice it, if its blocking, practice it. A good coach would tailor his practices to fix his teams weaknesses, not just do what everybody is doing.

by IhateUSuC on Nov 21, 2011 7:42 AM EST up reply actions  

Practices

High school coaches are amost always welcome to come and watch practices…..especially if there are players within your program that are being recruited by college programs. Swinney’s program is no different than most programs in this area

by oddfront34 on Nov 21, 2011 7:10 PM EST up reply actions  

Practice

You can practice all facets of the game of football without going full contact…… tackling, like any other fundamental skill should be broken down in every phase and then repetitioned…..daily!

by oddfront34 on Nov 21, 2011 7:17 PM EST up reply actions  

Paragraph breaks are your friend...

…I’m sure I’m not the only one who won’t read a giant wall of text like this.

by TolleyJenkins on Nov 21, 2011 10:10 AM EST up reply actions  

All the things you mention are true, but

We’ve had all those issues all season and still managed to win 9 games.

NCST didn’t suddenly “figure out” some perfect way to beat Clemson. They just played like it really mattered to them (and it did) and our guys didn’t. We didn’t HAVE to win this game. The division is already clinched. There was no sense of “must win” for the team. That was readily apparent.

Landon Walker said as much in an interview – something like “They just wanted it more. No one acted like this really mattered all week.”

This week is different. If they play like it doesn’t matter again (like they did 2 years ago) then we have a real problem.

There are plenty of flaws with this team, in all facets of the game; however, they can win games in spite of that if they play like they give a shit. If they just show up for a game of pickup coed flag football, they will get their asses whipped up and down the field again.

by Cristo on Nov 20, 2011 9:58 PM EST reply actions  

carolina dline is going to fucking eat this team alive , not one time do i recall a ncstate linemen being put on his ass and one of our players riding him to the ground.

by 5knklshfl on Nov 20, 2011 10:02 PM EST reply actions  

Recruiting

They have clearly missed on a number of these kids in the recruiting process. Watson, Shatley, Barnes and others. Shatley gives a lot of effort but he is one of the most unathletic defensive lineman I have seen at Clemson in a while. Watson, Barnes apparently are not even close yet and that is dissapointing. Hold on to the football, develop some rhythm on offense and give the defense some field to work with and you will see a different team. With all that being said it Dabo and boys have to teach these kids how to handle success and must win the games that they are supposed to if they want to take this program to the next level.

by oddfront34 on Nov 20, 2011 10:05 PM EST reply actions  

Not sure I'd dub Barnes a bust yet

He got himself into the doghouse with practice habits, but the staff still believes he is talented. I can’t say the same for Watson and I agree with your assessment of Shatley.

by ggggmen08 on Nov 20, 2011 10:51 PM EST up reply actions  

a little “humble pie” can be good at times……..whether we want to admit it or not

by oddfront34 on Nov 20, 2011 10:07 PM EST reply actions  

Discussing Rankings, standings etc

How do you guys feel about coaches discussing the rankings, BCS standings, etc with the players?? Dabo always says “We don’t talk about that, it’s not important to our goals”

But when LSU got ready to play Bama, they ALL understood what that game meant and what was in front of them during interviews. Those teams don’t stray from being top 5 or talking about being the best. Is it so bad to discuss the rankings with the team so they can understand what the hell they are playing for?? They need to be able to understand what it means to be a top 10 team- every week you’re taking someone’s BEST shot. And if you don’t show up, they will beat you!

I guess we just had to learn first hand.. Dabo said all along “2012 is our year”.. sadly we’ve passed up a golden opportunity in 2011.. Shame

"Just because you've had 2 or 3 good games doesn't mean anything right now. It's not the first 3 games you're going to be remembered by." - The Chad

by scgreatest803 on Nov 20, 2011 10:27 PM EST reply actions  

I agree with the idea that you shouldnt discuss rankings with your team.

Rankings dont matter to me, the next game does.

Actually i think 2013 sets up to be our year the best, assuming we can build an OL.

by DrB on Nov 20, 2011 10:29 PM EST up reply actions  

2013 Schedule

ACC home games: BC, Duke, FSU, Wake
ACC road games: Ga Tech, Maryland, NC State, Virginia

Can’t ask for a better ACC schedule than that. FSU at home and we get Duke and UVA from the coastal.

by ggggmen08 on Nov 20, 2011 10:56 PM EST up reply actions  

Mike London is building a program

at UVA. That probably won’t be anything resembling a cupcake by 2013

by PenthouseTiger on Nov 21, 2011 10:42 AM EST up reply actions  

He will do alright

But its still better than getting Va Tech.

by ggggmen08 on Nov 21, 2011 2:03 PM EST via mobile up reply actions  

I agree

In 2012 most of our swiss cheese OL will be graduated and we’ll be starting a bunch of redshirt freshmen and sophomores.

by PenthouseTiger on Nov 21, 2011 10:41 AM EST up reply actions  

I almost agree ,

the only problem I see for 2012 , and 2013 as well is if we still have the same HC , and the same S&C program then I don’t expect much change .

by tyeargin on Nov 22, 2011 12:20 AM EST up reply actions  

How can we build an OL DrB

unless Caldwell convinces Dabo that we need a major change at S&C , and that physical practice all around is priority ?
With the same S&C , and the same ole Bowden leftovers , I personally don’t expect much change . Great recruiting will not push DT’s and DE’s off the line alone . Hopefully “The Chad” will have major influence also , provided we can keep him .

by tyeargin on Nov 22, 2011 12:27 AM EST up reply actions  

Thats what I have thought about and hope happens. Maybe Chad or Caldwell goes

to Dabo and says there’s a need for a change in the S&C program/coach. I believe Morris is straightforward enough of a person, he’d go to Dabo and tell him straight out that our OL is fat, out of shape, and flat-out just pussies. And that’s all on Batson.

by IhateUSuC on Nov 22, 2011 1:08 PM EST up reply actions  

I wish I knew

you can only hope Dabo realizes that the multiple injuries, fat overweight linemen, and poor functional strength and explosiveness at the POA is due to Batson.

by DrB on Nov 22, 2011 6:11 PM EST up reply actions  

2013 Defenitely

LSU and Bama are completely different programs. They both have been in these situations before and are expected to contend for SEC Championship and beyond every year…..but if you listen to the video that Dr B and you can clearly see how Saban approaches every game. Dr. B, I agree that 2013 should be the best year. I expect us to struggle next year. Not to say 8-9 wins are not attainable, because they should always be attainable in the ACC (especially with the new additions …..Syracuse and Pittsburg). 2013 will feature a lot of talent and experience and experience equals championships.

by oddfront34 on Nov 20, 2011 10:38 PM EST reply actions  

Speaking of struggles next year

Can our offensive line possibly be any worse? The idea that it could really disgusts me, this unit simply has no heart or pride. True we don’t have good depth but a guy like McClain can’t claim to be tired, he hasn’t given one game’s worth of effort the entire F’ing season combined. I seriously hope Batson is gone after this year because it is clear our guys don’t have playing strength, mentally or physically.

On defense Steele needs to simplify things ASAP, if I see another series where not one of our back seven is set before the snap on almost every play I don’t think I’ll survive it.

by harcumcs on Nov 20, 2011 11:16 PM EST reply actions  

Great analysis, as always.

I’ve been a long-time lurker on this site, learning a great deal about everything about college football, in particular schemes, position responsibilities, and game analysis. I’ve always liked Clemson since Danny Ford won the national championship. And the ties between our two schools are strong.

I really can ’ t believe your OL and defensive woes. It ’ s hard to believe Swinney is a Stallings product. And the only mistake Stallings made, IMO, was Danny Pearman. It ’ ll be impossible to fire Swinney this year, so, unfortunately you have to do badly next year to get a coach who understands in football it ’ s OK to hit someone.

Anyway, a very belated congrats on beating Auburn and good luck.

by the thin red line on Nov 21, 2011 12:47 AM EST reply actions  

another appreciative bama fan here...

i’ve been interested in how saban’s CFB progeny have installed his particular system elsewhere and my suspicion is it is the elements such as this that probably have more to do with success than any specific schematic similarity.

following the alabama team, you hear a LOT of the coachspeak that national media outlets kind of gloss over in favor of more compelling storylines. but one that constantly re-emerges is this emphasis on fundamentals. for example… at the start of the two-week bye break prior to the LSU game, saban was quite open about what he was going to have the players do in practice: focus on fundamentals.

The way we try to manage our bye weeks here regardless of what’s happening down the road is to try to improve individually, and any deficiencies we have on our team, try to work on those specific areas so that we have a chance to get better," Saban said. "That’s certainly what we’re trying to do this week.

saban says a version of this each year and he’s stated similar comments prior to bowl trips as well. the point here is that he clearly sees the importance of refreshing fundamentals when the opportunity presents itself. you can teach players well but the routine of the season and more pressing preparations for particular foes lets those foundation skills atrophy a bit. a little sloppiness in week two can blossom to a full blown breakdown in execution six weeks later.

so maybe the issue isn’t the underlying means of training the clemson players, but the system in place to keep them focused on those fundamentals you see lacking. obviously, this is something that adds a bit of credence to your criticism of the program’s hyper-complex scheme.

Remember the Rose Bowl: The Story of the Alabama Crimson Tide & the Grandaddy of Them All

by kleph on Nov 21, 2011 8:42 AM EST up reply actions  

Yup.

Watching this game, it seemed like every single problem Clemson has had all season showed up all at once, thus the result. I would not be surprised to see Clemson lose to South Carolina, the Coastal champ, and lose the bowl game if they’re facing a semi-competent opponent.

If they look disorganized in 2012 and drop a game they shouldn’t, maybe Dabo will get fired and Morris can finally get rid of the Bowden holdovers.

by Clay Carroll on Nov 21, 2011 1:18 AM EST reply actions  

Amen

I would absolutely go nuts if we got a coach that had Harbaugh’s mentality, power running game and PA pass attack. That would be awesome and let’s face it, that’s the ONLY way to play football. You have to not just beat your opponent, you have to break them, and Stanford’s OL does just that.

Losing isn’t as hard to take when you are matching your opponent physically but we rarely do that, even in wins.

by judge jeff davis on Nov 21, 2011 6:56 AM EST up reply actions  

We do, Chad Morris talks about being tough and power running

But it takes more than talk to be tough. Apparently Dabo isnt letting them practice the way they need to practice to meet their goals. And also the S&C coach has been talked about a lot on here as well. It seems to be a combination of a lot of things. All those years of Brad Scott coaching them, their insufficient S&C routines, and Dabo’s soft practices. Its going to take a while to actually fix it, its not an issue that can be corrected overnight. One good thing is that a lot of the soft linemen are done after this year. Hopefully the young guys getting coached properly from the beginning by Caldwell will provide results.

by IhateUSuC on Nov 21, 2011 7:48 AM EST up reply actions  

You had one

You had a coach with that philosophy…….Billy Napier. However, the head coach could not keep his hands off of the play calling and constant overriding.

by oddfront34 on Nov 21, 2011 7:23 PM EST up reply actions  

Not advocating Napier

Not advocating Napier, but that was his philosophy…..Furman grad with power football background along with option

by oddfront34 on Nov 21, 2011 7:27 PM EST up reply actions  

Agree

Napier got the shit end of the stick. Dabo threw him under the bus.

by Sean McGarity on Nov 21, 2011 8:40 PM EST up reply actions  

The further we get from the NCST debacle

The more I think we’re definitely gonna lose in Columbia this week. First time I’ve said this since the Auburn game.

by tripp1 on Nov 21, 2011 2:46 AM EST reply actions  

Can Dabo fix it?

I think its a given that (on this site) Dabo isn’t our favorite. However after last season he identified a problem and corrected it by bringing in Morris. What are the odds he does the same thing this off season by either bringing in a new S&C or by having more contact in practices. Clemson has one of the most experienced coaching staffs in memory. Surely they are in his ear with those recommendations.

1 fan’s suggestion- Johnny Long is still hanging around in the Knoxville area after being let go by Lane Kiffin. I think we could lure Ethan Reeve from Wake too, he has coached at clemson previously.

by BuckTN on Nov 21, 2011 7:44 AM EST reply actions  

We can only hope

But Morris said he was going to work the guys hard in practice and to them a game would be a cakewalk compared to practice. Well apparently our spoiled, soft players didnt like that so they went to Dabo in the leadership council meetings and demanded less pads practice and Dabo instituted that policy.

Can’t get better, or be tougher with less practices. And now its showing in soft play on the field. They need harder practices.

by IhateUSuC on Nov 21, 2011 7:51 AM EST up reply actions  

He can if he chooses to

Whether he will, I do not know.

Its the same problems since before he got here, and he knew we werent physical up front under Bowden, and hasn’t fixed it yet.

by DrB on Nov 21, 2011 7:55 AM EST up reply actions  

another thing i cant understand is

we typically try to teach something in the same manner in which it was taught to us. Swinney was taught a kick in the teeth style of football at Alabama and it was successful to the utmost degree yet he tries to teach something different here. Just baffling

by BuckTN on Nov 21, 2011 9:32 AM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation site about the Clemson Tigers. If you want to take a hard look at both sides of something, feel free to stick around and comment. Be forewarned, we don't pump sunshine here.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Img2_small
Clemson Expansion: Big Picture
Small
2012 RULE CHANGES = THE WUSSIFICATION OF FOOTBALL
Clem_brawl-736603_small
Bellamy
Clem_brawl-736603_small
The state of Clemson Football (long)
Small
First hand (sort of) experience with Batson's system
Small
Somebody gets it
Small
Clemson Basketball Recruiting Chart
Angels_small
Brownell & Kansas State
Collegecampus_small
Frank Martin to coach USC Basketball
Small
Veteran Hopes to Fulfill Promise at Clemson.

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Bengal Tiger

Danny_ford_small DrB

Slick_small FIGUREFOUR

Persian Tiger

Tyree_helmet_catch_small ggggmen08

Small QuackingTiger

Sumatran Tiger

Sma_20clemson-tiger-w_20_2__small redbricktiger

Ellington_small Peter_G

Cj_spiller_heisman_small F1NS

Clemson-tigers-fans_the_wave_small SJTill